Home > Opinion
  print button email button

Friday, July 23, 2010

EDITORIAL

Minamata criteria slammed

In 1977, the government adopted strict criteria for the official recognition of people as victims of Minamata disease, Japan's worst pollution-induced affliction caused by Chisso Corp. Only someone suffering from a combination of methyl mercury-poisoning symptoms, such as sensory disturbances and visual field constriction, could be recognized as a victim. But on July 16, the Osaka District Court ruled that the criteria lacked medical legitimacy and ordered the Kumamoto Prefectural Government to officially recognize an 84-year-old woman as a Minamata disease victim. The ruling has been appealed.

The government has just started a new relief measure for unrecognized Minamata disease victims, featuring a lump-sum payment of ¥2.1 million and a monthly medical allowance of ¥12,900 to ¥17,700. But the ruling may encourage others to file similar lawsuits since an officially recognized victim qualifies for a lump-sum payment of ¥16 million to ¥18 million and other benefits. But there will be no guarantee that plaintiffs will win in court.

In October 2004, the Supreme Court ruled that a person with only one symptom of the disease should also be recognized as a Minamata victim if certain conditions — such as the official recognition of a family member as a victim — are met. Thus, it awarded ¥4.5 million to ¥8.5 million in compensation to the woman and 36 other people.

Despite this ruling, a state inquiry panel in March 2007 refused to officially recognize her as a victim. She filed a new lawsuit in May 2007. The July 16 ruling said that numbness in the limbs is sufficient to officially recognize a person as a Minamata disease victim if the person was exposed to methyl mercury for a certain period of time, if the numbness is peculiar to Minamata disease and if other causes are unlikely. It is the first ruling to order official recognition of a person as a victim under the revised Administrative Litigation Law.

The state must recognize that only a full revision of its 1977 criteria can realize a true solution to the Minamata disease issue. At the very least, it must conduct comprehensive health checks of residents in the areas polluted by Chisso's waste water.



Back to Top

About us |  Work for us |  Contact us |  Privacy policy |  Link policy |  Registration FAQ
Advertise in japantimes.co.jp.
This site has been optimized for modern browsers. Please make sure that Javascript is enabled in your browser's preferences.
The Japan Times Ltd. All rights reserved.